gasguide

/practice/journal-club / 2013

IMPROVE: Lung-Protective Ventilation in Intermediate-Risk Surgery

Futier E et al. A Trial of Intraoperative Low-Tidal-Volume Ventilation in Abdominal Surgery. NEJM 2013;369:428-437.

lung-protective · ventilation · abdominal · perioperative

Hook

VT 6-8 mL/kg IBW + PEEP 6-8 + recruitment cut postop pulmonary complications by 70%.

Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome

Population
400 adults at intermediate-to-high risk for postop pulmonary complications undergoing major abdominal surgery in France.
Intervention
VT 6-8 mL/kg IBW + PEEP 6-8 cmH₂O + recruitment maneuvers q30 min.
Comparison
Conventional VT 10-12 mL/kg IBW + zero PEEP, no recruitment.
Outcome
Composite of major pulmonary + extrapulmonary complications within 7 days.

Methods

Double-blind (clinicians blinded to ventilator settings via opaque dial covers — clever methodology), multicenter RCT. Randomization at induction.

Findings

  • Composite primary: 10.5% lung-protective vs 27.5% conventional (RR 0.40, P<0.001).
  • Pneumonia: 1.5% vs 8.0% (P=0.005).
  • Hospital LOS: median 12 vs 14 days (P=0.04).
  • Need for non-invasive ventilation: 1.5% vs 8.0%.

Clinical takeaway

Lung-protective ventilation (VT 6-8 mL/kg IBW + PEEP 5-8 + recruitment) is now standard for ALL intraoperative ventilation, not just ARDS. The cost is zero, the benefit is large. PROBESE 2018 confirmed PEEP titration > fixed PEEP in obese patients. Modern practice: calculate IBW from height (NOT weight), set VT, set PEEP 5-10 supine, recruit at 30-40 cmH₂O × 30 sec at induction + before extubation, target plateau <30, allow PaCO₂ 40-50 (permissive hypercapnia).

Limitations

  • Single-country (France) — surgical practices/recovery patterns may differ.
  • Composite endpoint includes both pulmonary + extrapulmonary — clean pulmonary signal is the dominant driver.
  • Did not separate effects of VT vs PEEP vs recruitment (later trials addressed each).

Discussion questions

  1. What's your default intraop tidal volume formula? IBW or actual?
  2. Do you use a fixed PEEP (5) or titrate? PROBESE-style or compliance-guided?
  3. Are recruitment maneuvers part of your routine extubation prep, or only on demand for desaturation?

← Back to all articles